Sleep training is a process of teaching a baby to fall asleep on their own and stay asleep throughout the night. Many parents struggle with getting their babies to sleep well, and may wonder if sleep training is the right option for them. There are different methods of sleep training, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. In this article, we will explore some of the most common sleep training methods, their pros and cons, and some tips on how to choose the best one for your baby.
The Ferber Method The Ferber method, also known as gradual extinction or check-and-console, is a sleep training method developed by Dr. Richard Ferber, a pediatrician and director of the Center for Pediatric Sleep Disorders at Children’s Hospital Boston. The Ferber method involves putting the baby to bed awake, and then leaving the room for gradually increasing intervals of time, while returning briefly to check and comfort the baby if they cry. The idea is to help the baby learn to self-soothe and fall asleep without relying on parental presence or assistance.
Pros of the Ferber Method
The Ferber method can be effective in reducing night wakings and increasing total sleep time for infants (Mindell et al., 2006).
The Ferber method can be adapted to suit different babies’ needs and temperaments, by adjusting the length and frequency of the check-ins.
The Ferber method can be less stressful for parents who are uncomfortable with letting their babies cry for long periods of time without intervention.
Cons of the Ferber Method
The Ferber method can still involve a significant amount of crying, which can be distressing for both babies and parents.
The Ferber method can be confusing or inconsistent for babies who may not understand why their parents are leaving and returning at different times.
The Ferber method can be challenging to implement if there are other factors that interfere with the baby’s sleep, such as illness, teething, growth spurts, or developmental changes.
The Cry-It-Out Method The cry-it-out method, also known as extinction or unmodified extinction, is a sleep training method that involves putting the baby to bed awake, and then leaving the room for the entire night, without returning to check or console the baby, regardless of how much they cry. The idea is to let the baby learn to self-regulate their emotions and fall asleep on their own.
Pros of the Cry-It-Out Method
The cry-it-out method can be effective in reducing night wakings and increasing total sleep time for infants (Mindell et al., 2006).
The cry-it-out method can be simple and straightforward to follow, without requiring any parental intervention or monitoring.
The cry-it-out method can be faster than other methods in achieving results, as some babies may stop crying and fall asleep within a few nights.
Cons of the Cry-It-Out Method
The cry-it-out method can involve a lot of crying, which can be emotionally and physically exhausting for both babies and parents.
The cry-it-out method can be perceived as harsh or neglectful by some parents who may feel guilty or anxious about leaving their babies alone.
The cry-it-out method can be difficult to maintain if there are other factors that disrupt the baby’s sleep, such as illness, teething, growth spurts, or developmental changes.
The Chair Method The chair method, also known as camping out or adult fading, is a sleep training method that involves putting the baby to bed awake, and then staying in the room with them until they fall asleep, while gradually moving further away from their crib each night. The idea is to provide the baby with reassurance and support while helping them transition to sleeping independently.
Pros of the Chair Method
The chair method can be gentle and gradual for both babies and parents who prefer a low-cry or no-cry approach.
The chair method can be reassuring and comforting for babies who may have separation anxiety or attachment issues.
The chair method can be flexible and adaptable to different babies’ needs and preferences, by adjusting the distance and duration of the parental presence.
Cons of the Chair Method
The chair method can be less effective than other methods in reducing night wakings and increasing total sleep time for infants (Mindell et al., 2006).
The chair method can be tedious and time-consuming for parents who may have to spend hours in their baby’s room each night.
The chair method can be counterproductive if the baby becomes dependent on the parent’s presence or attention to fall asleep.
The Bedtime Fading Method The bedtime fading method, also known as delayed bedtime or positive routines, is a sleep training method that involves adjusting the baby’s bedtime to match their natural sleep onset, and then gradually moving it earlier each night. The idea is to help the baby fall asleep quickly and easily by avoiding overtiredness and creating positive associations with bedtime.
Pros of the Bedtime Fading Method
The bedtime fading method can be gentle and natural for both babies and parents who prefer a low-cry or no-cry approach.
The bedtime fading method can be enjoyable and relaxing for babies who may benefit from a consistent and soothing bedtime routine.
The bedtime fading method can be flexible and adaptable to different babies’ sleep patterns and rhythms, by adjusting the bedtime according to their cues.
Cons of the Bedtime Fading Method
The bedtime fading method can be less effective than other methods in reducing night wakings and increasing total sleep time for infants (Mindell et al., 2006).
The bedtime fading method can be inconvenient and disruptive for parents who may have to alter their own schedules and routines to accommodate their baby’s bedtime.
The bedtime fading method can be challenging to implement if there are other factors that affect the baby’s sleep onset, such as naps, feedings, or stimulation.
The Pick-Up-Put-Down Method The pick-up-put-down method, also known as comfort settling or responsive settling, is a sleep training method that involves putting the baby to bed awake, and then picking them up and putting them down as needed to calm them down if they cry. The idea is to help the baby feel secure and loved while encouraging them to fall asleep on their own.
Pros of the Pick-Up-Put-Down Method
The pick-up-put-down method can be gentle and responsive for both babies and parents who prefer a low-cry or no-cry approach.
The pick-up-put-down method can be soothing and nurturing for babies who may need physical contact or affection to fall asleep.
The pick-up-put-down method can be flexible and adaptable to different babies’ needs and temperaments, by adjusting the frequency and intensity of the pick-ups and put-downs.
Cons of the Pick-Up-Put-Down Method
The pick-up-put-down method can be less effective than other methods in reducing night wakings and increasing total sleep time for infants (Mindell et al., 2006).
The pick-up-put-down method can be exhausting and frustrating for parents who may have to repeat the process multiple times each night.
The pick-up-put-down method can be confusing or stimulating for babies who may not understand why they are being picked up and put down repeatedly.
How to Choose the Best Sleep Training Method for Your Baby There is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to sleep training. Different methods may work better for different babies, depending on their age, personality, development, health, and environment. Likewise, different methods may suit different parents, depending on their goals, values, beliefs, and comfort levels. Here are some tips on how to choose the best sleep training method for your baby:
Do your research. Learn about the pros and cons of each method, and how they align with your parenting style and philosophy. You can consult books, websites, podcasts, or experts for more information and guidance.
Know your baby. Observe your baby’s sleep patterns, cues, habits, and preferences. You can use a sleep diary or an app to track your baby’s sleep data and identify their optimal sleep windows.
Know yourself. Be honest about your expectations, motivations, emotions, and limitations. You can use a self-assessment tool or a journal to reflect on your own sleep goals and challenges.
Be flexible. Be prepared to adjust your plan as you go along, depending on how your baby responds and how you feel. You can use a feedback loop or a support group to monitor your progress and make changes as needed.
Be consistent. Be committed to following through with your chosen method, as long as it is safe and appropriate for your baby. You can use a checklist or a reminder system to help you stick to your routine.
Conclusion Sleep training is a personal decision that depends on many factors. There are various methods of sleep training that have different pros and cons. The best sleep training method for your baby is the one that works for both of you. By doing your research, knowing your baby, knowing yourself, being flexible, and being consistent, you can find the best way to help your baby sleep well.
Leave a comment